Landmark Healthcare Anticompetition Case: News and Guidance From AMDR

The May 2025 jury verdict in Innovative Health, LLC v. Biosense Webster, Inc. is a watershed moment in the commercial device reprocessing, healthcare procurement, and broader medtech industries. Evidence and testimony entered during the trial exposed the anticompetitive practices the Johnson & Johnson MedTech unit used to undermine AMDR-member, regulated reprocessing companies – and how these practices inflated healthcare costs, undermined hospital choice, and risked compromising device quality.

AMDR invites clinicians, hospital procurement staff, regulators, journalists, and the public to review our news releases and statements about the case. We also direct hospitals to our Action Alerts, which provide practical guidance on how to withstand misinformation, coercion, and other anti-reprocessing conduct from certain OEMs.

AMDR’s full summary and analysis of the case is based on over 1,000 pages of unsealed court documents. It explains Biosense Webster’s anti-reprocessing conduct and highlights key evidence and testimony entered during the trial.

Court Documents:

August 27, 2025: Permanent Injunction (Judge Selna grants Innovative Health injunction)

July 21, 2025: Order Regarding Motion for Permanent Injunction (Judge Selna grants Innovative Health injunction, explains rationale, requests modifications)

July 2025: TENTATIVE Order Regarding Motion for Permanent Injunction (Judge Selna indicates he will grant Innovative Health injunction, explains rationale)

June 12, 2025: Innovative Health’s Proposed Permanent Injunction

June 12, 2025: Innovative Health’s Notice of Motion and Motion for Permanent Injunction (Innovative Health’s core arguments for injunctive relief)


All court documents linked on this page or in AMDR’s materials are unsealed and publicly accessible via PACER. Some have been highlighted by AMDR for readability.

AMDR’s Action Alerts and Technical Tips provide awareness and guidance on important industry developments that could impact your facility’s ability to deliver affordable, sustainable healthcare. Some of our Alerts are directly inspired by what was exposed in the case:

August 28, 2025: Court Prohibits Certain Anti-Reprocessing Tactics Following Innovative Health v. Biosense Webster Verdict

Lady justice Stock Photos, Royalty Free Lady justice Images | DepositphotosA federal court has issued a permanent injunction barring Johnson & Johnson’s Biosense Webster unit from interfering with reprocessing, following a trial in which the jury found the company liable for unlawful tying and monopolization. The court has barred Biosense from tying case support to device purchases, disabling reprocessed devices with chips, and hoarding used devices to cut off reprocessors’ supply.

This Action Alert explains the ruling, what hospitals should watch for, and how to report violations.

June 30, 2025: Reporting OEM Anti-Reprocessing Interference Following Innovative Health v. Biosense Webster Verdict

Lady justice Stock Photos, Royalty Free Lady justice Images | DepositphotosA federal jury has found a major OEM liable for unlawful tying and monopolization. AMDR has created a short form so hospital staff, supply chains, and reprocessors can report anti-reprocessing interference and route evidence to the right authorities. Reports may be submitted anonymously.

Read the Action Alert for the checklist of what to document, who to notify internally, and the downloadable reporting form.

June 12, 2025: Misleading Promotional Tactics by Medtronic Regarding Pulse Oximeter Sensors

Fact or fake concept flip blocks change the word fake to fact april fools dayMedtronic is marketing reprocessed Nellcor™ sensors as “remanufactured”—a label their FDA clearance doesn’t support—while pushing misleading superiority claims. They also limit sensors to one reprocessing cycle, inflating waste and emissions, while FDA data show multiple safe cycles are possible. Hospitals should verify claims against FDA filings, demand independent validation, and report misleading marketing.

Read the Action Alert for what to watch for, the questions to ask vendor reps, and next steps.